The latest market information was released this week by the Realtor groups, and it was hailed as great news. Sales up, foreclosures down, stability returning to the housing market.
On top of this was news that the 30-year rate for fixed rate mortgage hit an all time low of 3.83%. Taking such a mortgage is basically stealing money, because it provides a hedge against inflation, and makes it possible to borrow at a low rate while prices are still abnormally low. 3497 contracts were written last month in Central Florida and only 8642 units remain active and awaiting buyers. That means there is only a 2.47 month supply of homes throughout the area. And in some desirable areas, there are only a handful of homes from which to choose. We are now at the lowest level of inventory since the boom in 2005. And there does not seem to be any indication that the alleged flood of foreclosures will hit the market any time soon. Many of our agents are engaged in the kind of bidding wars that were last seen back in 2005 at the peak of the housing shortage. Back in mid January, a Seminole County judge reported he had 300 foreclosures to dispose of in a 3 day period. That would seem to indicate the end of the “foreclosure moratorium” that had been in effect last year after all the robosigning and government efforts to stop foreclosures. While the number of foreclosure sales has increased slightly, it has not flooded the market, and in fact, the active buyers are crying out for some home choices. Part of the reason is that the banks have gone “all in” on trying to avoid foreclosures by offering ridiculous terms to unload via short sales. I received this message this week from the largest holder of bad loans on the planet…Bank of America:
“That’s why Bank of America is excited to announce that for a limited time, we are offering enhanced relocation assistance payments in which qualified homeowners who initiate a short sale without an offer could be eligible to receive $2,500 – $30,000* in relocation assistance and owe no more on their mortgage with the sale of their property.”
$30,000 and a waiver of any further responsibility in exchange for getting out? Seriously? This is for people who in some cases have not made a mortgage payment in two years? Sounds like a pretty good deal. But here’s the catch: banks and governments have been so caught up in the political gamesmanship and public opinion of “avoiding foreclosures” that they are spending ridiculous amounts to allow short sales. But here in this area, and I am pretty sure elsewhere around the country in judicial states where foreclosures take 3, 4, even 5 years or more to happen (places like Florida where banks have to go through the courts to foreclose) a lot of homeowners face this scenario: They bought in the 2003-2006 timeframe when prices were rising faster than at any time in recorded history. But they fell like a rock between 2006-2011. That means owners are $50,000-$300,000 “under water.” They owe that much more than the value of the property. So, they have a choice. They can pay their payments, wait a generation for prices to return to what they were when they bought, or request a short sale, receive some cash back, but then have to go find a rental (and ever increasing rental prices). Many are taking the third option– they can stop making payments, wait in some cases five years for the bank to foreclose, and in the meantime, sock away hundreds of thousands of dollars. This will allow them to purchase a home with cash and never require the good graces of a bank ever again! Ruins their credit, but other than that, a more positive alternative than paying for rent or mortgage in a home not increasing in value. Opting out of making legitimate payments, even without a hardship. Two years ago no one would have even thought about taking such a choice. People were largely embarrassed to stop making payments, and did not want anyone to know. But those days are gone, as more and more people are bragging to their friends and neighbors about not making payments and all the money they are saving. Such a story even made the front page of the Orlando Sentinel this year.
The banks have taken the usual route—payoffs to delinquent payers. The government has taken the usual route—let’s legislate against foreclosure so these folks can stay in their homes. But the real losers in this deal are you and me. Through our taxes, fees to banks, and general willingness to make our loan payments, we get nothing but government debt. While our homes are worth less than any time in the past 10 years. Responsibility is still a virtue, and I thank God the overwhelming number of homeowners choose to pay their debt. The more people “opt out,” the longer it will take to crawl out the hole that the banks and the government continue to dig deeper. There is a simple solution that would raise prices and bring true free market system back into play and a free economic system again able to build the country:
Make all states non judicial recourse states. This means you, Florida lawmakers! In Texas, it takes about 3-6 months to foreclose instead of the 3-5 years here. If people who had hardships were allowed short sales, and everyone else would know they would be out in a short period, they would not opt out of payments. And in about 6 months, you would see a return of the free market economy which built our state and nation into a powerhouse. Anything less is simply pandering and unworthy of re-election. Readers, you do have a choice. Let me know your thoughts and comments.